Is it better to get a replacement window (with frame) or just replace the glass?
saurin13 asked:
I have a double pane window that is many years old and very cheap (came with the house, maybe 1/32″ panes). I want to change the windows because the noise from outside and nearby train is very easy to hear. The two options I have are: full replacement of the window with new vinyl frames to a double pane window (1/8″, 1/8″+laminate+1/32″) or just replace the double pane with something better (1/8″, 1/8″+laminate+1/32″). The price difference is that the second option is about 25% less than getting it with brand new frames. Also the first option is with LowE3 and a super-spacer. The second option uses LowE2 and aluminum spacer.
I have a double pane window that is many years old and very cheap (came with the house, maybe 1/32″ panes). I want to change the windows because the noise from outside and nearby train is very easy to hear. The two options I have are: full replacement of the window with new vinyl frames to a double pane window (1/8″, 1/8″+laminate+1/32″) or just replace the double pane with something better (1/8″, 1/8″+laminate+1/32″). The price difference is that the second option is about 25% less than getting it with brand new frames. Also the first option is with LowE3 and a super-spacer. The second option uses LowE2 and aluminum spacer.
I am concerned that getting the second option, with just new windows and using my existing frames and panes (which are in decent condition) will not be sealed properly as the complete replacement.
Any recommendations?
Ivonne
February 21st, 2010 at 6:54 pm
Larraine
In the big picture, it would be cheaper and probably easier to replace the whole window. You would then have lastest technology, warranty, and better insulating values all around. With the other option, you risk things not fitting properly, which causes down time, aggrevation, and mostly your time and money.
February 25th, 2010 at 2:36 am
Lucila
I would opt for the full replacement vs the glass replacement. This would give you a factory warranty and I suggest you look into the warranties. It may cost you a little more initially but in the long run you will be better off. And, you will also be eligible for an energy tax credit. This is based on my own personal experience but I did a very quick search and found the following link. P.S. Save your receipts.
February 27th, 2010 at 11:43 am
Lenore
i have double panes in my new house. doubt u will get railroad noise releif.